I haven't been designing much lately but I decided to post the last two sigs I made.

Serious constructive criticism only. No "oh that's cool", or "oh I like it", stuff. Good suggestions please





UPDATE:

First some seems like there might be too much brushing. I also think the stock could be blended better.

On the second one, I think you sharpened the render too much on the face, if it wasn't sharpen, then it was a layer style... Either way, its too strong, and pulls away from the rest of the sig, I think if you fixed that, it'd work.

On the second one it was a layer style I used in my attempt to work with a TERRIBLE quality render >_> I'll try blurring it and re-upping it.

The First one comes together quiet well

The Second one, its ether too bright on her face, or her whole body, i cant put my finger on it, try toning the brightness down, see if that makes it look a bit better.

Updated.

Much better. I haven't anything else to rant about it now.

better, but try lowering it till you can at least clearly see her nose. I think then it will be good =]

Second one is way saturated . Like in a way bad way. Is one of your layers on Color Dodge? Cause sometimes it causes an image to be that supersaturated. If one is on CD try toning down the Luminosity

I think, it's really a helpful and creative post to me.